Breville Infuser Vs Gaggia Classic: Detailed Comparison

I get commissions for purchases made through links in this post. Read more

Comparing the Breville Infuser vs Gaggia Classic, I’d say the Breville Infuser is the better one since it maintains temperature stability with its PID, and its pre-infusion feature is a significant advantage for preventing channeling. As for the Gaggia Classic, you’d either need to modify it to include a PID controller or get accustomed to temperature surfing, which can be quite frustrating for beginners.

Breville Infuser Vs Gaggia Classic: Specs & Features Comparison Chart

Image
THE WINNER (#1)
Breville Infuser Espresso Machine BES840XL, Brushed Stainless Steel
THE RUNNER-UP (#2)
PrimaDonna Class
Model
Breville Infuser
Gaggia Classic
Dimensions/Weight
12.3 x 10.2 x 13.1 inches/17 lbs
14.2 x 9.5 x 8 inches/18.7 lbs
Interface
Button-Operated Interface
Button-Operated Interface
One Touch Drink Options
2
2
Built-in Grinder
Grinding Settings
Heating System
Single Thermocoil
Single Aluminum Boiler
Pump Pressure
15 Bars
15 Bars
Pre-Infusion
Milk Frothing System
Manual Steam Wand
Panarello Steam Wand
Spigot Type/Cup Clearance
Dual/4.5 inches
Dual/3.3 inches
Water Reservoir/Bean Hopper
1.8 L/None
2.1 L/None
Filter
Yes (Optional)
Compatible With Pre-ground Coffee
App Connectivity
User Profile
What I Like
Price
$539.98
N/A
More Info
Not Available
THE WINNER (#1)
Image
Breville Infuser Espresso Machine BES840XL, Brushed Stainless Steel
Model
Breville Infuser
Dimensions/Weight
12.3 x 10.2 x 13.1 inches/17 lbs
Interface
Button-Operated Interface
One Touch Drink Options
2
Built-in Grinder
Grinding Settings
Heating System
Single Thermocoil
Pump Pressure
15 Bars
Pre-Infusion
Milk Frothing System
Manual Steam Wand
Spigot Type/Cup Clearance
Dual/4.5 inches
Water Reservoir/Bean Hopper
1.8 L/None
Filter
Yes (Optional)
Compatible With Pre-ground Coffee
App Connectivity
User Profile
What I Like
Price
$539.98
More Info
THE RUNNER-UP (#2)
Image
PrimaDonna Class
Model
Gaggia Classic
Dimensions/Weight
14.2 x 9.5 x 8 inches/18.7 lbs
Interface
Button-Operated Interface
One Touch Drink Options
2
Built-in Grinder
Grinding Settings
Heating System
Single Aluminum Boiler
Pump Pressure
15 Bars
Pre-Infusion
Milk Frothing System
Panarello Steam Wand
Spigot Type/Cup Clearance
Dual/3.3 inches
Water Reservoir/Bean Hopper
2.1 L/None
Filter
Compatible With Pre-ground Coffee
App Connectivity
User Profile
What I Like
Price
N/A
More Info
Not Available

Last update on 2024-05-19 / Affiliate links / Images from Amazon Product Advertising API

Breville Infuser Vs Gaggia Classic: Differences

The Breville Infuser came out on top against the Gaggia Classic with a score of 4-0 in my head-to-head comparison. Let’s read on to explore!

Coffee Flavor & Brewing System

Winner: Breville Infuser

Built-in Grinder 

You might find these machines a bit limiting if you don’t already own a coffee grinder since they come without one. But if you have your own grinder or you are okay with pre-ground coffee, it’s not much of a barrier for you. And if you want to explore all the brewing possibilities, you could always invest in a conical burr grinder.

Dosing & Tamping

The Gaggia Classic uses a 58-mm commercial-grade portafilter, which is quite impressive, but the tamper is made of plastic and is terrible. It’s too flimsy and not heavy enough to do the job, so you’ll need to buy a separate stainless steel tamper.

The Breville Infuser, on the flip side, comes with a 54mm portafilter. Its tamper is far from perfect, but it’s not bad at all. Incidentally, it can also be attached to the machine’s body for neat storage.

the infuser uses a 54-mm portafilter
The Infuser uses a 54-mm portafilter

Both ship with two sets of filter baskets: a pair of pressurized baskets and a pair of non-pressurized filter baskets. Receiving four filter baskets is a bit like discovering extra fries at the bottom of a fast-food bag – unexpected but a delightful surprise. Many manufacturers tend to take away the option of pressurized or non-pressurized, even though they know that each type has its own role.

Pressurized filter baskets are a better fit for beginners or those who prefer pre-ground coffee, offering a more forgiving brewing process. On the other hand, non-pressurized baskets are often the go-to for achieving superior extraction, even though they may require a bit more finesse.

Heating System

These machines have just one boiler, so they can’t pull a shot of espresso and froth milk at once. For most of us, the few seconds of wait time is no big deal. But if you’re really serious about milky drinks like lattes and cappuccinos, consider splurging on a dual-boiler machine.

The Breville Infuser, with its thermocoil heating system, heats up faster than the Gaggia Classic, which uses an aluminum boiler. To compare, the Breville Infuser reaches the right temperature within one minute, while the Gaggia Classic is ready to go in around two minutes.

The differences might seem minor, but they truly make a difference. I mean, in the rush of a chaotic morning, every single second counts, doesn’t it?

Brewing System

While I’m on the subject, I should say that the Breville Infuser has pre-infusion, while the Gaggia Classic doesn’t. Still, you can manually pre-infuse on the Gaggia Classic by slightly opening the steam knob, pressing the brew button for seconds, then turning the steam knob off, and you can start full extraction.

If you’re curious about pre-infusion, it is all about gently wetting the coffee grounds with low-pressure water before starting the full extraction process. This step is crucial because it helps the coffee grounds swell and settle, leading to a more even extraction of flavors when full pressure is applied.

Pressure, right, 9 bars of pressure is the minimum for proper extraction. Both use a 15-bar pump, so they’re more than capable of getting the job done well, without a doubt.

Ultimately, the Gaggia Classic also has no PID, so you have to modify it to add PID or temperature surf to get convincing results.

Design & Convenience

Winner: Breville Infuser

Dimensions & User Interface

Breville InfuserGaggia Classic
Dimensions12.3 x 10.2 x 13.1 inches14.2 x 9.5 x 8 inches
Weight17 lbs18.7 lbs

Coming to dimensions, they’re compact enough that they won’t crowd out other kitchen appliances. Both are encased in stainless steel, providing both a sleek appearance and robustness. It doesn’t matter which part you consider- the upper portion or the wand – the build quality’s strength is evident throughout.

Controlling Breville Infuser is as easy as a piece of cake. There are only four buttons on its front-facing control panel. Nestled in between is a Pressure Gauge, so you can get a clear picture of what’s happening with my espresso with just a glance.

the infuser's control panel
The Infuser’s control panel

The Gaggia Classic is even more minimalist with just 3 buttons for turning the machine off, brewing, and steaming. It’s just a matter of minutes to get used to everything, trust me.

Spout Type & Cup Clearance

Breville InfuserGaggia Classic
Spout TypeDualDual
Cup Clearance4.5 inches3.3 inches

Their cup height is pretty standard for espresso cups, but the Gaggia Classic can pose a bit of a challenge if you’re using something larger like a tall latte macchiato glass, something. So if you need the extra room, you can just remove the drip tray grille.

Water Reservoir & Bean Hopper

Breville InfuserGaggia Classic
Water Reservoir1.8 liters2.1 liters
Bean HopperNoneNone

The Gaggia Classic boasts a slightly larger water tank, which is definitely a plus, but it lacks a handle and removing it is a bit tricky. Fortunately, you can just fill the tank from the top of the machine, which is quite convenient.

The Breville Infuser’s tank is not bat at all and has a slot for the included water filter. If you’re curious about the filter. It is used to remove impurities from water, enhancing the coffee’s flavor and extending the machine’s lifespan.

Milk Frothing System

Winner: Breville Infuser

The Gaggia Classic comes with a Panarello wand, while the Breville Infuser boasts a manual one. I appreciate the user-friendliness of the Panarello wand – you simply immerse the frother in your milk without worrying about the angle or depth to create the perfect vortex.

Still, the Panarello wand struggles to create microfoam with the velvety texture needed for latte art. For those aiming to craft latte art, the Breville Infuser, with its manual wand, is the better choice.

the breville infuser uses a manual steam wand
The Breville Infuser uses a manual steam wand

Personally, I lean towards manual steam wands over automatic ones. They offer more control, which is crucial for achieving delicate milk foam. The Breville Infuser’s wand rotates 360 degrees and there is a control knob on the side. By the way, the Breville Infuser comes with a stainless steel milk jug, whereas the Gaggia Classic doesn’t

Drink Options & Programmability

Winner: Breville Infuser

Drink Options

Breville InfuserGaggia Classic
Espresso
Hot Water
Espresso
Hot Water

In addition to brewing espresso, both also have the option of pulling out hot water through a dedicated hot water outlet. So whenever you’re in the mood for a cup of tea or even a quick bowl of soup, this handy feature is a lifesaver.

the infuser has an outlet for hot water
The Infuser has an outlet for hot water

Programmability

Adjustable SettingsBreville InfuserGaggia Classic
Coffee StrengthNoNo
Coffee TemperatureNoNo
Milk Foam TemperatureNoNo
Milk Foam TextureNoNo

The Gaggia Classic has no PID so it has no option to change the coffee temperature, and it only allows you to manually control the shot length. The Breville Infuser, with its PID, lets you adjust the coffee temperature in 4°F increments.

I know, 4 degrees might not seem significant at first, it can dramatically affect the quality of your espresso. Temperature plays a crucial role in extraction, so those few degrees could be the deciding factor between a perfect espresso and a bitter, nearly undrinkable shot.

Quick Rundown Of Breville Infuser

Sale
Breville Infuser Espresso Machine BES840XL, Brushed Stainless Steel
  • Earn up to $200 cashback with a Beanz coffee subscription when you purchase a selected Breville espresso machine. Visit earn-cashback.breville.com purchase to claim. Valid Aug 1, 2023 until Jun 30, 2024
  • The Breville Infuser delivers optimal flavor in every cup creating third wave specialty coffee at home using the 4 keys formula, ensuring the right dose of beans, optimal water pressure, precise temperature control and microfoam milk for latte art
  • VOLUMETRIC AND SHOT CONTROL: Control the volume of each pour at the touch of a button and choose 1 shot, 2 shot or manually control over how much espresso ends up in your cup for the perfect dose every time
  • OPTIMAL WATER PRESSURE: Low pressure pre-infusion gradually increases pressure at the start and helps ensure all the flavors are drawn out evenly during the extraction for a balanced tasting cup
  • PRECISE ESPRESSO EXTRACTION: Maximize flavor potential with low pressure pre-infusion, digital PID temperature control, adjustable in 4 ?F increments complete with pressure gauge that guides you to the right extraction every time

Last update on 2024-05-19 / Affiliate links / Images from Amazon Product Advertising API

Pros
  • Thermocoil fast heating system.
  • High-quality steam wand.
  • On the compact side.
  • Adjustable pre-infusion.
  • Not expensive.
Cons
  • One boiler.
  • No grinder.

Quick Rundown Of Gaggia Classic

Pros
  • Compact footprint.
  • Beginner-friendly Panarello wand.
  • Well built.
  • Cheap.
  • 58-mm commercial-grade portafilter.
Cons
  • The tamper is cheap and flimsy.
  • No PID.

Product Videos

Related Articles to Breville Infuser

  1. Breville Infuser Vs Gaggia Classic Pro: Which One Is Best For You?
  2. Breville Infuser vs Bambino Review: What Is The Right Choice?
  3. Breville Duo Temp Pro vs Infuser: Which Espresso Machine Performs Better?
  4. Breville Dual Boiler Vs Infuser: Which Is Best For You?
  5. Breville Infuser vs Barista Express: Is A Built-in Grinder Worth It?
  6. Breville Bambino Plus vs Infuser: Which Should You Buy?
  7. Breville Cafe Roma Vs Infuser: Which One Is Your Best Bet?

Related Articles to Gaggia Classic

  1. Gaggia Classic Vs Gaggia Classic Pro: What Are The Differences?
  2. Breville Bambino vs Gaggia Classic: Which Is The Better Cut-Price Espresso Machine?
  3. Gaggia Classic vs Pro: What Is The Most Iconic Semi-Professional Espresso Machine Under $500?
  4. Delonghi Dedica EC685 vs Gaggia Classic: Which Is More Beginner-Friendly And Which Is More Barista-Like?
  5. Breville Duo Temp Pro Vs Gaggia Classic: Which Machine Is Easier To Operate And Brews Better Coffee?
  6. Gaggia Brera vs Classic – Super-Automatic Or Semi-Automatic Espresso Machine?

References:

5/5 - (4 votes)