Flair 58 Vs Gaggia Classic Pro: 1 Classic And 1 Alternative Espresso Machine. Which One Do I Prefer More?

I get commissions for purchases made through links in this post. Read more

After getting my hands on Flair 58 vs Gaggia Classic Pro debate, I have found my ultimate winner: Gaggia Classic Pro.

The winner Gaggia Classic Pro boasts of its well-rounded design that is easy to handle and can brew rich espresso. The interface is minimal to ensure a straightforward brewing experience, and the steam wand can froth creamy milk foam for beverages like latte, latte macchiato, flat white, mocha, etc. I highly recommend this affordable machines for beginners and first-timers.

As for Flair 58, I’m really impressed by the modern design of this model. It offers a 100% manual experience for a niche group of users. However, this is also its biggest weakness. From my perspective, it might be too complicated and inconvenient for many users. I will elaborate further below.

Flair 58 vs Gaggia Classic Pro: Comparison Chart

Image
THE WINNER (#1)
Gaggia RI9380/46 Classic Pro Espresso Machine, Solid, Brushed Stainless Steel
THE RUNNER-UP (#2)
Flair 58
Model
Gaggia Classic Pro
Flair 58
Dimensions (LxWxH)
9.5 x 8 x 14.2 inches
14 x 7.5 x 11.5 inches
Weight
20 Pounds
8 Pounds
Color/ Material
Silver / Stainless Steel
Black/ Aluminum, stainless steel, wood
Water Reservoir Capacity
71 oz
Not specified
Level of Automation
Semi-automatic
Fully manual
Power / Voltage
1425W / 110V-120V
Not specified
Noise-free Operation
Visible water level
Fast Heat Up
Decompression duct
Water tank position
Frontal
External
Interface
Buttons
Lever
Bar Pump System
15 bars
Max 12 bars
Heating System
Single boiler
Brew head (boiler)
Milk system
Steam wand
None
What I Like
Price
$449.21
$830.00
THE WINNER (#1)
Image
Gaggia RI9380/46 Classic Pro Espresso Machine, Solid, Brushed Stainless Steel
Model
Gaggia Classic Pro
Dimensions (LxWxH)
9.5 x 8 x 14.2 inches
Weight
20 Pounds
Color/ Material
Silver / Stainless Steel
Water Reservoir Capacity
71 oz
Level of Automation
Semi-automatic
Power / Voltage
1425W / 110V-120V
Noise-free Operation
Visible water level
Fast Heat Up
Decompression duct
Water tank position
Frontal
Interface
Buttons
Bar Pump System
15 bars
Heating System
Single boiler
Milk system
Steam wand
What I Like
Price
$449.21
More Info
THE RUNNER-UP (#2)
Image
Flair 58
Model
Flair 58
Dimensions (LxWxH)
14 x 7.5 x 11.5 inches
Weight
8 Pounds
Color/ Material
Black/ Aluminum, stainless steel, wood
Water Reservoir Capacity
Not specified
Level of Automation
Fully manual
Power / Voltage
Not specified
Noise-free Operation
Visible water level
Fast Heat Up
Decompression duct
Water tank position
External
Interface
Lever
Bar Pump System
Max 12 bars
Heating System
Brew head (boiler)
Milk system
None
What I Like
Price
$830.00

Last update on 2022-05-25 / Affiliate links / Images from Amazon Product Advertising API

Flair 58 vs Gaggia Classic Pro: Differences

Gaggia Classic Pro wins 3-1 against Flair 58. I believe that Flair 58 is a good espresso machine, but its design seems too peculiar for the general public. Also, Flair 58 offers more automatic functions in every aspect. The quality of the espresso is excellent as well. I will tell you how these machines work for me compared to how they are advertised. 

Coffee Flavor: Tie

+Dosing + tamping

Dosing and tamping are both manual with these machines. But there is a slight difference in how the steps work. 

With Gaggia Classic Pro, the pump pressure system works automatically to start extracting coffee. And when I find the dose sufficient, I manual turn off the extraction process. This model uses 15 bars pump pressure to extract. So the flavor is quite nuanced and robust. 

As for Flair 58, even the pressure needs to be applied manually. This is the function of the lever. I have to pull it while keeping a tab on the pressure gauge to ensure that the pressure is right around 8 to 10 bars. As for the flavor, I think it’s nutty and balanced.  

Flair 58: Dosing + tamping
Flair 58: Dosing + tamping

+Heating system 

If my investigation is correct, both devices use a single boiler system to heat water. Why am I not sure if this info is correct or not? Allow me to elaborate further.

Gaggia Classic Pro owns a single boiler, and the brand confirms this. Thanks to the boiler, I have extracted hot and steaming espresso, which might result rare for this particular heating element. I find the overall temperature performance of this product line impressive. With its cheap price tag and stable operation, I believe this one will be worth the small investment. 

As for Flair 58, I find it hard to identify the exact brewing element of this model since the brand doesn’t specify the information, and the part itself isn’t removable either. In fact, the brew head shouldn’t be called a “brewing element” since this is not exactly what it does. 

I have to pre-brew water, pour the hot water inside the 90ml brew head, and start the extraction. The brew head itself provides low to high temperature, which is adjustable. And the maximum heat that this compartment emits is around 197.6F. Technically, we can heat water with this brew head. But I don’t find the process stable and efficient.  

Milk System: Gaggia Classic Pro

Flair 58 doesn’t even have a milk system, so Gaggia Classic Pro wins the round. But this is not the sole reason why this model wins. I actually enjoy its commercial style milk wand. According to the advertisement, this wand can easily froth from creamy to microfoam.

Gaggia Classic Pro can easily froth from creamy to microfoam
Gaggia Classic Pro can easily froth from creamy to microfoam

And here is how it really works from my experience. Microfoam isn’t its biggest strength since I have tried frothing it many times, but the thickest and airiest texture that I get is more appropriate for lattes. And as a result, the milk texture is more than ideal for this kind of beverage. I can even do some simple latte arts with the foam. In terms of foam temperature, we get a hot one with this kind of system.

In conclusion, I find the steam wand very pleasant for the price of this machine. It’s an affordable model that can deliver creamy foam for many recipes. I’m satisfied with what I get so far. 

Utilities: Gaggia Classic Pro

Since Flair 58 is a fully-manual machine, it’s not surprising that it doesn’t have as many convenient additional features as Gaggia Classic Pro. With Gaggia Classic Pro, I like that it has a dedicated decompression duct that presses all the water in the used puck after brewing so that the puck results drier and easier to dump out. 

Also, I like that the water tank of Classic Pro is totally transparent, and it has a line that indicates the maximum water level that it can store. It makes keeping up with the refills much easier. 

On top of Gaggia Classic Pro is a cup warming tray. It receives heat passively from the boiler right underneath.  

Design & Material: Tie

In terms of material, these machines are mainly made of stainless steel, which is excellent since it’s rust-free and very durable. I have nothing to complain about as for this aspect.

The design part is what troubles me because it depends a lot on each user’s preference. For me, I value convenience and simplicity more, especially in espresso machines of this price range. Therefore, I prefer Gaggia Classic Pro, given I’m used to its classic espresso machine design and functionality.

Flair 58, on the other hand, has a more manual control with its lever. The overall visual aspect of this machine is very unique. It can froth delicious espresso, and it looks like a contemporary piece of furniture. I think users who pay attention to design for all these reasons will prefer this one more.

And you? Which style do you prefer?

Flair 58 using portafilter, combined with temperature keeping system
Flair 58 using portafilter, combined with temperature keeping system

Flair 58 vs Gaggia Classic Pro: Similarities

Gaggia Classic Pro and Flair 58 don’t have many similarities between them. But the noise-free operation and the decent temperature performance are 2 points that I find pleasant in both machines. 

Noise-free operation

The pair is good at brewing espressos without making too much noise. This is the aspect that I expect in most espresso machines that aren’t integrated with a bean grinder. These devices are good choices if you hate the grumbling or screeching sound an espresso machine makes during grinding, extracting, and frothing. 

Good temperature performance

I enjoy the temperature performance of both machines. They can keep the drinks hot. But, it’s evident that working with the temperature of Gaggia Classic Pro is more direct and convenient, given that I only have to hit the button and start brewing. 

With Flair 58, I have to brew water with an electric kettle beforehand, then pour the steaming water in the brew head. The brew head is hot, so it maintains the heat well. But this is more like the work of my kettle instead of the espresso machine. 

Quick Rundown of Gaggia Classic Pro

Gaggia RI9380/46 Classic Pro Espresso Machine, Solid, Brushed Stainless Steel
1,690 Reviews
Gaggia RI9380/46 Classic Pro Espresso Machine, Solid, Brushed Stainless Steel
  • Rugged Brushed Stainless Steel housing
  • Commercial three-way solenoid valve. Capacity water tank - 2,1 liter
  • Commercial-style 58mm chrome-plated brass portability and brew group
  • Commercial steam wand. Rotating steam want movement type
  • Easy-to-use rocker switch controls

Last update on 2022-05-25 / Affiliate links / Images from Amazon Product Advertising API

Pros
  • The secure mounting reduces noises during the brewing process significantly
  • Giant water tank which is suitable for office or big families
  • Consistent espresso extraction
  • The cup warming tray can heat up to 120°F and helps maintain the coffee temperature longer
Cons
  • Milk texture is not dry enough for cappuccinos

Quick Rundown of Flair 58

Pros
  • Unique design, perfect for users who hunt modern furnitures with a twist
  • Manual control over the pump pressure
  • Good coffee crema
  • Delicious espresso with hot temperature
  • Simple control, perfect for beginners
Cons
  • The design might result complicated for many users
  • No milk system
  • Users have to brew water separately

Product Videos

Related Articles to Gaggia Classic Pro

  1. Gaggia Classic Pro Vs Quickmill 820: Top 4 Differences Between 2 Classic Espresso Machines
  2. Flair Pro 2 Vs Gaggia Classic Pro: Comparing 4 Crucial Aspects Of 2 Espresso Machines. Peculiar Vs Classic!
  3. Rancilio Silvia M Vs Gaggia Classic Pro: 2 Straightforward Espresso Machines With Good Feedbacks. Are They For Real?
  4. Lelit Anna 2 Vs Gaggia Classic Pro: 2 Straightforward Espresso Machines For Beginners. Which Brews Better Coffees?
  5. Gaggia Classic Vs Gaggia Classic Pro: Is There Any Difference Between These Espresso Machines? Find The Better One
  6. Lelit Anna Vs Gaggia Classic Pro: Reviewing 2 Affordable Espresso Machines For Offices. Which Is More Worth To Buy?
  7. Gaggia Classic vs Pro: What Is The Most Iconic Semi-Professional Espresso Machine Under $500?
  8. Breville Bambino Plus vs Gaggia Classic Pro: Reviewing Automation Level, Espresso Flavor, Additional Features Of 2 Very Distinctive Models
  9. Breville Infuser vs Gaggia Classic Pro: Which Is The Must-have Espresso Machine?
  10. Breville Bambino vs Gaggia Classic Pro: Reviewing 2 Cut-Price Espresso Machines For Homeowners
  11. Breville Duo Temp Pro vs Gaggia Classic Pro: Comparing Espresso Flavor, Water Tank Capacity, And Other Factors
  12. Breville Barista Express vs Gaggia Classic Pro: Which Is Better Innovation?
  13. Gaggia Brera vs Classic Pro – What Is The Best Automatic Espresso Machine?
  14. Compare & Buy Gaggia Carezza Deluxe vs Classic Pro: Which Is For You?

References:

5/5 - (1 vote)